The Q1 Journal Education Sciences awarded the 2026 Best Paper Award to Dr. David Ernesto Salinas Navarro, research professor at the School of EngineeringUniversidad Panamericana, for an article proposing an innovative pedagogical framework to integrate Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) into the design of experiential learning activities in higher education.
The award, the researcher explains, represents “deep professional satisfaction and the validation of a rigorous effort to contribute tangible solutions to the field of education”. The distinction was based on high-impact metrics, such as download and citation volume, as well as the paper’s selection as anEditor’s Choicearticle from among more than 1,600 articles published in 2024. “The fact that this award considers these metrics demonstrates that the proposal has resonated both practically and intellectually within the global scientific community”, he notes.

A Pedagogical Framework to Counter the Passive Use of AI
The article stems from a gap identified by Dr. Salinas: most initial approaches to GenAI in higher education focus on ethical considerations, algorithmic capabilities, or the passive use of the tool to summarize information.
“I identified a clear need to provide a deliberate pedagogical framework in which GenAI serves to foster critical thinking and experiential learning,”, he states. His proposal, he emphasizes, “guides faculty in designing interactive activities capable of exposing students to real-world scenarios and complex problem-solving.”
The researcher explains that the cornerstone of the model lies in framing GenAI as a “cognitive scaffold” and co-designer of learning experiences, rather than merely an answer-retrieval engine. Grounded in David Kolb’s experiential learning cycle, the framework enables instructors to use AI to design roles, contextualized activities, and dynamic case studies that adapt to students’ decisions.
“It differs from other approaches in thatit neither seeks to automate teaching nor replace human judgment; rather, it places the student in an active role of experimentation, whereAI acts as a reflective interlocutor or an interactive environment that requires critical analysis and real-time decision-making,” he clarifies.

Ethical Challenges: Preventing “Cognitive Atrophy”
Regarding the challenges of adopting these tools, Dr. Salinas warns that the primary hurdle “lies in preventing ‘cognitive atrophy’ or blind faith in algorithmically generated outputs.”
Among the priority ethical considerations, he lists the following:
- Bias and equity (ensuring that models neither reproduce nor amplify cultural, gender, or socioeconomic biases).
- Transparency and privacy of student data.
- Redesigning assessment to focus on the thought process and critical reflection beyond the final product.
- Promoting learner agency so that students do not delegate their responsibility or decision-making.
How Does Artificial Intelligence Reshape the Role of Faculty?
For the “ Universidad Panamericana ” scholar, the emergence of GenAI “accelerates the transition of the educator from a ‘transmitter of knowledge’ to an architect of learning experiences and a human mentor”. The traditional paradigm, centered on rote memorization or basic content production, “becomes obsolete.”
“In the coming years, pedagogical value will lie in the ability to ask the right questions, discern the quality of information, and design environments in which students apply human values—such as empathy, ethics, and critical judgment—in collaboration with technology”, he maintains.
From this perspective, integrating artificial intelligence into education does not eliminate the professor’s role; rather, it places greater demands on student mentorship and holistic development.

Toward Ecosystems That Strengthen Student Agency
Looking ahead, Dr. Salinas envisions an evolution aimed at strengthening student agency within complex sociotechnical ecosystems. “AI must not make decisions or replace human thought; rather, it should serve as an interactive environment that challenges students to take ethical responsibility for their choices,”, he concludes.
The 2026 Best Paper Award thus recognizes research from Universidad Panamericana that addresses the intersection of generative artificial intelligence, educational innovation, and experiential learning, from a perspective focused on fostering critical thinking and student accountability.
This recognition enhances the international visibility of research conducted at Universidad Panamericana and strengthens its participation in scholarly dialogue on the impact of emerging technologies in higher education.
Learn more about researchers at the Universidad Panamericana at: https://www.up.edu.mx/investigacion/




